Club Rating: 4.1
Outstanding for a debut novel. Most didn't like the wife and found her weak. They felt that he knew that the mother was going to be taken care of by the neighbor. The police officer wasn't believable. An interesting point was raised that Mia could have told him that she was behind it at any point to change the outcome. Everyone liked that each chapter designated if it was BEFORE or AFTER and who was writing. Some found the plausibility questionable and the character and story development.